Interview with Hernando De Soto, Author of The Mystery of Capital
Teamwork in the 10th Millennium B.C.
Livable Cities

(Lecture Notes, Copyright. Dr. Bruce M. Firestone, Ottawa, Canada. December 2002.)

Affordable Housing in Africa


Substandard Housing in Botswana
(from Habitat for Humanity http://www.habitat.org/)


Index:

  1. Needs Analysis
  2. Economic Model- the difference between affordable in the west and in Africa; some spreadsheet comparisons and incomes; the differences within Africa—upper tier, middle tier and lower tier: median incomes versus average incomes. Source: http://www.worldbank.org/data/databytopic/GNPPC.pdf which highlights the difference between currency exchange and PPP (Purchasing Power Parity) and why materials, services and technology must all be local for success; locally available materials- e.g., Bill Teron’s failed experiment, where he imported pre-tensioned concrete elements toAfrica.
  3. Locally Available Technology- wind up radio, pedal powered electricity, the kybo plug, the Firestone apple picker, drilled well/salt problem
  4. Give a Fishing Rod, not a Fish: unlocking hidden capital- role of private property, ownership and real estate values, co-ops, kibbutz, African tribal values- sharing firewood with Koni, child raising, borrowing circles, micro business, micro loans to females and the net- the African model ?
  5. Teamwork and Synergy: cities, towns and villages save the environment and lay the foundation for growth- Jane Jacobs + Teamwork in the 10th Millennium B.C.
  6. Work, Live, Play + Internet Connections
  7. Village Governance- Mobutu’s goats and Bongama’s vegetable garden

1. Needs Analysis

AFFORDABLE HOUSING IS NEEDED THROUGHOUT THE WORLD (http://www.habitat.org/how/intlstats.html)

Currently there are some 1.2 billion people worldwide experiencing "income poverty," meaning they live on the equivalent of less than one dollar per day. 1

The United Nations Centre for Human Settlements (UNCHS) has estimated that 1.1 billion people are living in inadequate housing conditions in urban areas alone. 2

UNCHS has estimated that some approximately 21 million new housing units are required each year in developing countries to accommodate growth in the number of households during the period between 2000 and 2010 period. Some 14 million additional units would be required each year for the next 20 years if the current housing deficit is to be replaced by 2020. 3

In Latin America, households need 5.4 times their annual income to buy a house. In Africa, they need an average of 12.5 times their annual income.

The highest rents are found in the Arab States, where a household spends an average of 45 percent of its monthly income on rent.

Real estate costs are highest in Asia and the Pacific where one square meter of land for a serviced plot costs an average of $3.10 in U.S. dollars.

PEOPLE WORLDWIDE NEED DECENT HOUSES IN DECENT COMMUNITIES.

Less than 20 percent of households in Africa are connected to piped water, and only 40 percent have piped water within 200 meters of their home.

In the developing world, 29 percent of cities have areas considered as "inaccessible" or "dangerous" to the police. In Latin America and the Caribbean, this figure is 48 percent.

In cities of the developing world, one out of every four households lives in poverty. Forty percent of African urban households are living below the locally defined poverty line.

Less than 35 percent of cities in the developing world have their wastewater treated.

In countries with economies in transition, 75 percent of solid wastes are disposed of in open dumps.

CITATIONS:

1 World Bank. 2000. World Development Report, Washington, Table 1.1.

2 UNCHS (Habitat). 1999. Basic Facts on Urbanisation, Nairobi, p. 9.

3 UNCHS (Habitat). 1999. Basic Facts on Urbanisation, Nairobi, table 9.

4 UNCHS (The United Nations Centre for Human Settlements) State of the Cities Report 2001 March

2. Economic Model

Affordable Housing Model

27-Nov-01

Note: All Dollars are US Currency

Ottawa

Your New Home

$125,000

Equity

25%

$31,250

Mortgage

$93,750

Your Annual Household Income

2

$20,000

$40,000

Your Annual Mortgage Costs

25

7%

-$8,044.74

Housing Costs/Household Income

20%

Ghana-- Imported Materials and Services Model

Housing Costs/Household Income

20%

Your Annual Household Income

2

350

$ 700.00

Your Annual Mortgage Costs

$ 140.78

Mortgage

25

7%

$1,640.63

Equity

25%

546.875

Your New Home

$2,187.50

Ghana-- Local Technology, Materials and Services

Housing Costs/Household Income

20%

Your Annual Household Income

2

1940

$ 3,880.00

Your Annual Mortgage Costs

$ 776.00

Mortgage

25

7%

$9,043.18

Equity

25%

$ 3,014.39

Your New Home

$12,057.57

You can afford a lot more House if you invest in local technology, materials and services.

Also, housing is a 'local' industry-- it produces jobs where the people are if you use local tech, etc.

The multiplier effect is much greater then!

This Model will only work if there is a capital system in place-- a means to recycling money;

i.e., a banking system with mortgages, recognition of property rights and

a title system, etc.

Copyright. Dr. Bruce M. Firestone, Ottawa, Canada. November 27, 2001.

3. Locally Available Tech and Materials

Technology and materials that are appropriate to the circumstances and that are locally available and sustainable are one of the keys to solving the affordable housing issue in developing nations. By using local technology, local employement and local materials, one is working in the local currency which makes much higher levels of output possible from a limited buget. Also, the results are such that these homes can be maintained using local expertise and repaired using local materials.

Some examples of local technology are given below.

In one of the Appendices, a past resident of a Kibbutz describes his efforts to get acceptance for a new low tech devide to improve applea harvests there. The story involves: a) a description of the apple picker, b) its uses, c) its rejection by the “everyone is equal except some are more equal than others” kibbutz hierarchy (George Orwell), d) re-ordering of Kibbutz assignments in protest, f) expulsion of the member, g) redemption and adoption of the Apple Picker, h) use spreads around the planet showing up in ... Ontario twenty years later.

Wind up radio

Pedal powered electricity

The kybo plug

Drilled wells and the salt problem

4. Give a Fishing Rod, Not a Fish

Micro-Enterprise Loan Funds focus on helping low-income people start their own businesses. Using a peer-lending model, each borrower is paired with other borrowers who are starting their own businesses. Together the loan recipients are responsible for each group member’s loan and collectively benefit from education and technical assistance provided by the micro-enterprise fund. Many organizations around the world have created banks and loan funds based on this model.

Habitat homeowner Jennifer Nabirye and affiliate chairperson Juliette Waisa dance in front of a Habitat house in Jinja, Uganda. (2001)


Property Rights, Human Rights and Economic Development

In Canada at the beginning of the 1980s, then Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau wanted to entrench property rights in the Canadian Constitution in the Charter of Human Rights. He was vigorously opposed in this by most, if not all, of the Provinicial Premiers. Why? Because they felt entrenching such rights would or could encroach on Provincial authority of eminent domain- the ability to expropriate land, regulate land use, pass rules and regulations concerning mineral extraction, set environmental standards and so on.

Mr. Trudeau felt, I believe, that property rights are also fundamental to human rights; that unless people are protected from unreasonable infringement of their property rights, there can be no real personal freedoms. If governments can grab your land, take your business, well, it isn't a big step to taking away your personal freedom or even your life.

Property rights are also fundamental to economic development. To this day, most startups are, one way or another, financed with home or other building and land equity. If an entrepreneur owns a home, he or she will pledge it for startup capital from a bank. If Mom or Dad or rich Uncle Buck are helping out, their homes or other personal property are probably somewhere in the loop as collateral.

In many developing countries, they either don't have a sophisticated and extensive enough banking system to bring mortgages to the masses or they discourage private ownership of property. In Mexico, one of the goals of new President Vincente Fox is to bring the financial system into line with North American standards so that home ownership becomes an attainable goal for the middle classes. Even if you have 50% or 75% cash equity, you still can't get a home mortgage in Mexico today.